Custom homebuyers have asked what we think about luxury vinyl tile. Here’s our answer.
We don’t often talk about products in this newsletter, but when lots of clients ask about a specific one, we like to offer our thoughts. That’s the case with luxury vinyl tile flooring, or LVT. We’re not the only ones getting questions: according to some articles we’ve read, LVT is one of the world’s fastest-growing floor coverings.
These products are sold as planks or tiles. Some are glued in place, and others are installed as a floating floor. Many have a photo-realistic surface layer that mimics natural wood or stone. They’re better looking than conventional vinyl, as well as thicker and more durable. They’re more difficult to scratch than site-finished or engineered hardwood, and if a piece gets damaged it’s generally easy to replace.
An LVT floor will cost less than natural stone and resist water better than hardwood. That makes it a reasonable choice for rough-use areas like mudrooms and finished basements. Some products can even be safely installed over radiant floor heat.
Of course, no product is perfect for every application, and we discuss at length the pros and cons with custom homeowners before they make a final decision. We feel that sharing our understanding and research helps our clients make the best possible choice for their family.
Let’s start with aesthetics. Even though LVT products are attractive, you need to make sure you actually like the look. For instance, manufacturers advertise their plank products as being nearly indistinguishable from real hardwood. They do come close, but “indistinguishable” is a stretch, and in fact a lot of customers mistake the planks for wood-look ceramic tile. There’s nothing wrong with that; the only question is whether it’s what you want.
There’s also the cost. Many people assume that a faux-hardwood LVT plank will be less expensive than real wood, whether engineered or site-finished. But that’s not necessarily so, and you may be able to get a beautiful, site-finished hardwood floor for less.
One reason for LVT’s high price is rising demand from homeowners. Another is that a quality job often requires the installer to place an expensive engineered underlayment between the vinyl and the subfloor or slab. The underlayment provides cushioning, muffles sound, and in the case of basements prevents moisture from migrating up through the concrete and getting trapped beneath the vinyl.
Finally, there’s the issue of water from above. LVT products are marketed for use in wet areas like baths, and they are indeed waterproof. However, if the floor will be habitually wet, or if a broken pipe floods the room, water can seep in around the edges.
You can minimize the chance of water-related issues by choosing the right product type. LVT comes in glue-down and floating varieties. If water gets in around the edges of a glue-down floor, the problem will stay at the edges and you’ll probably only need to replace a few boards or tiles. With a floating floor, by comparison, water can seep further underneath. Part of the finished floor may need to be removed to prevent mildew problems or damage to the wood subfloor.
The bottom line is that Luxury Vinyl Tile is great for certain situations. But like most engineered products, it needs to be chosen wisely and installed in a way that ensures long-term durability. That requires a firm understanding of how the product will perform over the long term, and it’s why Merlin Custom Home Builders make a point to educate themselves on the latest product trends.